What the Red Ryder Actually Does to Small Game
The Daisy Red Ryder carbide rifle is one of the most famous BB guns in American history. It fires a .177 caliber steel BB at roughly 350 feet per second, which comes out to about 9 to 10 foot-pounds of kinetic energy. That number matters more than anything else in this discussion. Squirrels are small animals, yes, but they are also dense. Their skulls are thin but their brains are tiny targets. A single BB strike to the body might wound a squirrel without killing it outright, and a wounded squirrel is a cruel thing that will crawl off and die slowly. That is not what anyone wants.
Will A Red Ryder Kill A Squirrel Separating Fact From Fiction
Here is the straightforward answer. A Red Ryder can kill a squirrel under very specific conditions. The conditions are not forgiving. You need a clean head shot with the BB hitting the brain case directly. Even then, the probability of an instant kill drops off sharply compared to a proper airgun or a real firearm. Most hits to the body region will not drop the animal quickly. The BB often just passes through or flattens on impact, leaving the squirrel in pain and still mobile. I learned this the hard way a few years back. I was at a friend's property shooting at what I thought was a tree squirrel sitting still. I got a clean body shot from about 20 yards. The BB hit the rib area. The squirrel dropped, twitched for maybe ten seconds, then got up and ran three feet before falling again. It was dead eventually, but not from a single instant kill. I spent the next twenty minutes figuring out how to put it out of its misery with a rock because I had not brought anything suitable for that purpose. That was my fault, not the gun's entirely, but it was a messy outcome I would rather not repeat. So if you are asking whether the Red Ryder is a viable squirrel rifle, the honest answer is that it is not. It is a toy gun that can accidentally kill a small rodent if everything lines up perfectly. That is not a reliable hunting setup.
The Physics Behind the Problem
Let us talk about energy transfer. A .177 BB weighing 8.4 grains at 350 fps carries approximately 9.1 foot-pounds of energy. For comparison, a standard .22 rimfire round delivers about 120 to 140 foot-pounds. The difference is massive. A .22 hollow point designed for small game will expand on impact and dump that energy into the target in a controlled way. The BB does not expand. It does not deform. It either punches through or deforms minimally and loses energy unpredictably. Steel BBs also tend to flatten against bone. When that happens, the energy transfer becomes even less efficient because the flattened BB loses velocity rapidly and may deflect off the skull rather than penetrate. This is why a head shot is technically possible but extremely difficult to achieve consistently. You are aiming at a target the size of a dime from twenty feet or more, with a gun that was never designed for precision shooting. The Red Ryder also has a natural point of aim that shifts depending on the distance. At twenty yards, a typical BB will drop about six to eight inches from the point of aim. That means your kill zone shrinks dramatically. A body shot at that distance is almost never lethal. A head shot requires compensating for drop while also accounting for wind drift, which a Red Ryder iron sight setup makes nearly impossible for most shooters.
Get the Full Details

What Actually Works for Squirrel Hunting
If your goal is to hunt squirrels humanely, there are better options. An airgun in .22 caliber firing a lead pellet at 800 to 1000 fps will deliver around 80 to 120 foot-pounds of energy. That is in the right ballpark for clean kills on squirrels at typical ranges of ten to forty yards. Pellets like the H&N Baracuda Match or the JSB Exact Juo also perform well because they are designed to mushroom on impact and deliver rapid energy transfer. A .22 caliber rimfire is overkill for squirrels in most situations but it is the gold standard for reliability. You get instant kills at any reasonable distance with proper shot placement. The recoil is manageable and the ammunition is cheap. Here is something most beginners miss. The issue is not just the gun. It is the ammunition choice. Even with a proper .22 airgun, using a thin-walled target pellet will result in poor expansion and weak kills. You need hunting pellets with heavier skirts and proper design. I once used a budget brand of .22 pellets on my FX Discovery and got through-thru shots that did not drop squirrels immediately. Switching to H&N Ferrogold and the results changed completely. Same gun, same shooter, totally different outcome.
The Legal and Ethical Side
Depending on where you live, using an airgun or any firearm for squirrel hunting requires a license and falls under specific season regulations. In some states, there are minimum foot-pound requirements for hunting with airguns. A Red Ryder fails those requirements in nearly every jurisdiction that has them. Check your local fish and wildlife department before you go anywhere near a squirrel with any projectile device. The ethical question is straightforward. If you cannot achieve a quick kill, you should not be shooting at the animal. Wounding game is not a hobby. It is a failure of preparation and equipment selection. The Red Ryder is fine for plinking. It is fine for target practice at twenty-five yards when you are just enjoying the sound and the brass casing. It is not fine for hunting. The gap between fact and fiction on this topic is wide, and the fiction usually comes from nostalgia for movies and cartoon references. Reality does not care about your childhood memories.
Use the right tool for the job. Squirrels deserve a clean end. You deserve a good hunt. The Red Ryder gives you neither when put to that use.
